E.P. Carrillo Short Run 2023 Toro

The E.P. Carrillo Short Run 2023 Toro begins with a confident medium-to-full-bodied profile, offering a bold fusion of dark cocoa, roasted coffee bean, and aged cedar underscored by a natural molasses sweetness. The first puffs reveal a measured black pepper kick on the retrohale, intertwined with hints of cinnamon and clove, providing a warm, spiced frame to the blend’s richness. As it transitions into the second third, flavors of toasted walnut, caramelized sugar, and dried fig emerge, creating a layered complexity that balances the cigar’s deeper earth and wood tones. The final third crescendos with espresso crema, charred oak, and bittersweet chocolate, finishing long with a spice-laced woody sweetness that lingers elegantly.

For more detailed cigar and whisky pairing recommendations, explore our comprehensive guide to finding the perfect match for your smoking experience.

The construction is superb, showcasing a dark, satiny wrapper with a fine oil sheen, perfectly applied over a densely packed binder and filler. The Toro vitola is rolled with consistent firmness from head to foot, capped expertly, and free from visible imperfections. The cold draw reveals notes of cocoa husk, cedar, and raisin, while ignition produces dense, aromatic smoke through a flawlessly tuned draw. The burn remains sharp and even throughout, requiring minimal correction, and the ash forms tight, silvery-gray stacks that hold securely.

An ideal whisky pairing is the GlenDronach 18 Year Allardice, whose rich sherry cask influence of dark fruits, toffee, and baking spice complements the cigar’s cocoa, cedar, and molasses tones while enhancing the retrohale’s warm spice.

Discover more about premium whisky selections that complement your cigar collection.

This cigar has notable aging potential, with 5–8 years likely to bring greater integration of its sweetness, spice, and earthy core, yielding a smoother, more cohesive profile.

Overall, the E.P. Carrillo Short Run 2023 Toro is a masterfully balanced smoke that delivers depth, complexity, and impeccable construction, making it an ideal choice for those seeking a cigar that excels both fresh and with careful aging.